Initially, prostate stimulation might make you feel like you need to pee a bit, but this is just your body readjusting to a sexual response from stimulation. After a. “Anal sex feels like someone is stimulating every erogenous part of my body. It's like trying to squeeze out the last of your good moisturizer and. 9 Things You Need To Know Before Trying Anal Sex. For starters, it can feel really, really good. By Zahra Barnes. For that matter as well, never go back to vaginal sex without changing condoms. You could get horrible infections from that. - Relax a lot beforehand. Your anus.